Garmin + Wahoo Fitness HR Open Water & Race Solution (Heart Rate Monitor)

IMG_3676

Wahoo TICKR-X pod on a new style Garmin strap

The open water season is most definitely upon us. Hopefully you’ve already managed a few swims as it’s not too cold, I’ve done 4 and I’m a bit of a cold water wimp. It’s fine.

However I’m looking at HR for my open-water swims. Obviously I’m not going to be looking at my HR as I swim (although maybe after a lap getting the average might be useful for some). However I would like to know what it was afterwards (I measure training load through TRIMPs).

Along a similar vein as the race season for tri’s is now upon us I would really like to know how hard I tried in the swim sections.

The rest of this is geared towards Garmin owners. You smug Suunto Ambit3 Sport (Reviewed Here) owners and Polar V800 owners are probably already OK 🙂

My Preferred Option: WAHOO TICKR-X (Reviewed Here) HR pod on a new style Garmin strap (more info here). The Wahoo pod CACHES the data and you can upload it later via their APP. AT THE SAME TIME IT WILL ALSO SEND HR DATA to your watch just as any other HR strap does.

Advantages: This option will work for pretty much any watch. Whatever HR you can’t pick up from the strap (which supports ANT+ and BTLE) on your watch or smartphone you can get it later via their APP. The new Garmin strap has more sensors and I’m currently seeing if this is more accurate and/or longevitous.

Disadvantages: You will get an incorrect HR data track for the swim component because of drop-outs (indeed it may be entirely blank) and you will have to overwrite that track later. You will only get HRV from data recorded onto your 910/920 as the wahoo app only, currently, supports TCX export which does not contain HRV R-R data.

Summary: Looks good to me so far!

IMG_3430

Some other HR Pods. Suunto SMART BELT, GARMIN HRM-RUN, POLAR H7, WAHOO TICKR-X

Another Option: MIO Link (or similar optical HR for wrist). If you put this right next to your Garmin 920XT (only) AND if your watch is in open-water swim mode you should record a HR track (but will not be able to see it as you swim).

Advantages: You get the HR data in the swim data track.

Disadvantages: water ingress to sensor area might cause dropouts, you probably would want to rely on the same MIO for bike+run. This might be less accurate at high HRs. You might choose to wear a chest strap as well for the bike/run.

Summary: Probably OK for training, perhaps not for racing.

Garmin HRM straps through time

Garmin HRM straps through time

Black Friday 2015 Amazon UK Amazon USA
4iiii Viiiiva V100 HRM £79.99 Link $77.64 Link
4iiii Viva Mini TBC
SMS Bio Sport Ear Bud £40.97 Link $69.99 Link
Garmin Heart Rate Monitor (Hard) £31.00 Link $39.09 Link
Garmin HRM-RUN (Soft) £51.36 Link $99.99 Link
Garmin Premium (Soft) £31.89 Link $39.99 Link
Garmin HRM-Swim £76.00 Link $98.99 Link
Garmin HRM-Tri £96.52 Link $129.99 Link
Jabra Sport Pulse £99.00 Link $123.10 Link
LifeBeam Smart Helmet n/a Link $185.49 Link
MIO Fuse £94.95 Link $129.95 Link
MIO Link £58.95 Link $61.51 Link
MIO Velo £84.35 Link $111.19 Link
Polar H6 £54.50 Link $42.99 Link
Polar H7 £37.49 Link $51.45 Link
PowerTap PowerCal ANT+ £104.49 Link $95.99 Link
PowerTap PowerCal Bluetooth £87.53 Link $95.99 Link
Scosche Rhythm+ £70.00 Link $79.95 Link
Suunto Smart Belt £43.68 Link $54.91 Link
Under Armour Armour39 $62.99 Link
Wahoo RFLKT £71.99 Link $89.99 Link
Wahoo RFLKT+ £79.99 Link $128.57 Link
Wahoo TICKR £44.14 Link $59.85 Link
Wahoo TICKR-RUN £64.99 Link $71.92 Link
Wahoo TICKR-X £79.90 Link $99.90 Link

2 thoughts on “Garmin + Wahoo Fitness HR Open Water & Race Solution (Heart Rate Monitor)

  1. I have owned a Garmin Forerunner since November 2014 and I am very disappointed with the erratic peroformance of its HRM. After the first couple of months, it started malfunctioning and it now gives me a credible reading every five or six training sessions. Is there anything I can do to correct this problem? Is there a battery inside that must e replaced?
    Thank you

    • Hi enrico. That shouldn’t happen. First look at the official garmin care instructions.
      1. you should always unclip at least one end of the pod to avoid th epotential for a circuit and battery drain when not in use
      2. you need to wear it properly and fairly snug/tight
      3. yes there is a battery. it should last longer than a year for most people.
      4. it could be the battery or it could be the strap. so find a friend and do a swap of the pods to find out if it is the pod or the strap. THEN you will know what to do

Leave a Reply