Wahoo Tickr Fit Review | Best Optical Heart Rate Monitor?

In this Wahoo Tickr Fit Review we will take a look at the first arm-worn optical heart rate monitor from Wahoo Fitness.

Wahoo generally provide good, innovative products that are compatible with a wide range of other sports products.

Wahoo Tickr Fit Review

Background

Optical heart rate monitors located on your wrist, ie with a sports watch, are prone to potentially significant errors. It’s hit-and-miss as to whether an optically-based watch will work with YOU. But the same technology worn further up the arm, usually on your upper arm, will probably work VERY well for almost all of us.

Optical HR technology is now relatively mature and well understood by manufacturers. Some device manufacturers buy-in the optical sensor from companies like Valencell but, in this case,  Wahoo seem to have decided to go it alone to some degree.

Accuracy is a big issue but so too is battery life. There is a ‘need’ in some parts of the consumer market for 24×7 heart rate monitoring. I’m not entirely sure how well-justified that ‘need’ is but, hey, if you guys want it, the manufacturers try to let you have it.

Accuracy and battery life also fit into overnight heart rate monitoring. Providing the battery can last 10 hours, or so, this use-case might support checking sleep quality and sleep cycles especially when combined with a motion sensor. But if an optical HR monitor can be sufficiently accurate to produce HRV (RR) data at resting levels then further insights may be offered to athletes looking to quantify recovery, adaptation and readiness-to-train in some fashion. This can already easily be accomplished with a chest strap but I don’t know anyone who would wear a chest strap EVERY night…maybe an arm band is a more practical alternative?

Background: Manufacturers & Products

MIO made the first optical wrist bands. We then saw the Scosche Rhythm (and Rhythm+) arm band. There are cheap OEM/generic bands waiting to hit the market in Q1.2018. Polar produced the OH1 arm band in 2017 and, in January, Scosche released their 2018 version, the Rhythm 24. Most new sports watches incorporate an optical HR sensor.

Wahoo make excellent cycling products, including the ELEMNT and KICKR. They also have a good pedigree with their innovative TICKR HR chest straps which have innovative feature like providing cycling/running cadence. I have a rather neat Wahoo Tickr-X (reviewed here). Let’s see what Wahoo’s first foray into all things optical is like.

Wahoo Tickr Fit Review

This will be a relatively short review as the product is relatively straightforward. Let’s go.

Unboxing & Contents

Wahoo Tickr Fit Review

 

In the box you get the optical pod and straps of two lengths. There is a proprietary charging cradle that will plug into a standard USB port.

Wahoo Tickr Fit Review

‘Quite’ long

The straps are just over 20cm and just over 30cm long. However 20cm and 30cm are the maximum arm circumferences each will support.

Wahoo Tickr Fit Review

Nice blue button – you won’t miss that.

The sensor array comprises 3 green LEDs. Sometimes a mixture of light colours is thought to be best. Only Polar have a 6 LED sensor array (green only).

There is a multi-coloured LED on the exterior to indicate if the TICKR FIT is turned on and its status.

There’s a blue on-off button on the side.

You get paper as well. To summarise the quickstart guide: “turn it on” then “pair it”

Usage: Pointers and Comments

Exterior LEDs

Let me tell you about the exterior LED first of all. Most usefully note these:

  • Flashing green = charging
  • Solid blue = on/transmitting
  • Rapid Red Flash – turning off

The Strap

The strap is more important than you might, at first, think. The original Scosche Rhythm had issues with strap longevity and the current Polar OH1 has issues with strap flippability when pool swimming – I have both of those devices.

The Tickr Fit’s strap feels like it will last. I’ll try to remember to update wear issues in a couple of months.

This is how you fit the strap, with the fluffy Velcro on the outside.

Wahoo Tickr Fit Review

 

Here are the width of each of the main bands:

  • Scosche Rhythm+ – 28mm
  • Wahoo Tickr Fit – 25mm
  • Polar OH1 – 25mm

The OH1 is thinner as it does not work by fastening with velcro.

You could use the Wahoo’s narrower strap in the Scosche but NOT the other way round.

My upper arm does not sweat much and what sweat there is seems to be more than adequately wicked away by the strap design.

Strap official specs: Small 260mm x 25.4mm and Large 375mm x 25.4mm. Length includes the fastening rough, velcro tab.

Wearing It

You can probably wear it however you want and wherever you want; as long as you don’t cover the sensor array! There should be no need to overtighten the Tickr Fit to get a good reading.

Turning It On

The blue button needs a good press and hold for 3 seconds; I would imagine it is unlikely to be turned on by accident.

The Blue exterior LED initially flashes but turns solid quickly thereafter. Presumably once a HR signal is detected.

Pairing

You know what to do folks…

Wahoo Tickr Fit Review

Suunto Spartan Trainer – Awesome and already paired via Bluetooth Smart

You should be able to pair the Tickr Fit to any Bluetooth Smart or ANT+ compatible device, including many Apple and Android apps. You would pair it as an external HR monitor, just the same as for a chest strap.

Wahoo Tickr Fit Review

Elemnt Bolt – Awesome

You should be able to simultaneously pair the Tickr Fit with many ANT+ devices AND one Bluetooth Smart device. You can only ever have one active Bluetooth Smart pairing although you should be able to have made several Bluetooth Smart pairing. Having multiple Bluetooth pairing is not generally advisable as you may well find that your device will not pair because it is currently inadvertently ACTIVELY paired to, for example, your smartphone. I guess once you ran out of range of that smartphone it should pair up to the other device you are wearing (I’ve never tried that!) but some sports watches REALLY want you to have all sensors paired and active before heading off.

Wahoo Tickr Fit Review

Garmin 935 – Super Great

Devices like Wahoo’s Elemnt bike computer or Garmin’s high-end watches, like my Forerunner 935, can all pair to either Bluetooth or ANT+ sensors. They all seem to prefer to initially connect to the Tickr FIT via ANT+. I’m fine with that, despite other people suggesting that a Bluetooth connection is better.

Zwift compatibility? A: Yep.

Polar Gym Link compatibility? A: No.

Wahoo Tickr Fit ReviewBattery & Charging

 

Battery life is very good and stated as 30+ hours.

The cradle is slightly magnetic and this holds the Tickr Fit to the cradle whilst charging

Charging whilst recording HR is not possible as the sensor must point into the cradle whilst charging.

However if you turn the device on and then place it on the cradle it does not turn off and may still transmit (although there will be nothing to transmit). This behaviour is irrelevant at present but IF caching is introduced in the future then you may want to preserve one continuous session interrupted by a period of zeros whilst charging…there could be some ULTRA running scenario here that I can’t quite think of.

Caching / Memory

The Tickr Fit probably has the hardware to cache heart rate. Such a feature is NOT enabled at present (if it exists).

Caching/Storage is possible with the Polar OH1 and Scosche Rhythm 24.

Underwater Use

The strap complies to IPX7.

You could probably get a signal to travel underwater to a sports watch if you wore the Tickr FIT immediately next to the watch.

HRV App Usage

The Tickr Fit does NOT appear to be able to connect to apps that require a HRV-enabled heart rate monitor (I only tried Bioforce HRV)

Accuracy – Provisional

So far I have seen no reason to think this is not sufficiently accurate for running and cycling usage.

Here is a more formalised ‘test’ at different levels of running intensity

HRM-TRI vs TICKR-FIT

clickable

Some turbo shinanigans

clickable, Tickr Fit started about 10 mins in

Possibly  a slight under-reading at the higher effort level?

And more…summing up my testing frustrations (and a great device!)

Boring, Boring, Boring. Review Data Comparison

The following is a slideshow of various (clickable) HR charts. I’ll add more over time if anything interesting crops up. There has only been one low level turbo session where the Tickr Fit was a couple of beats under where it should have been. I’m not overly concerned with that. Then another where the HRM-TRI was wrong at the start!

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Comparisons Wahoo Tickr Fit Review

Here are some thoughts on the comparison to the Polar OH1 and the Scosche Rhythm+

Wahoo Tickr Fit Review - Polar OH1

Fit vs OH1

The Polar Oh1 is a very much smaller device. You can see that the profile of the Polar OH1 and Tickr Fit is lower than that of the Scosche.

Wahoo Tickr Fit Review - Scosche Rhythm+

Fit vs. Rhythm+

I think the Scosche Rhythm+ has had its day. Good bye and thank you for the ride. It was good.

There is some new v3 firmware for the Rhythm+. Some older Rhythm+ devices are not upgradable and even when upgraded there are reports of the new firmware trashing the device. And all the new firmware brings is a few peripheral features like providing cadence. Here are some sobering notes to that effect (Link to: licomatic.com). Advice: If it ain’t broken don’t fix it. 🙂 You’ll break it. Although that will then give you an excuse to buy the Tickr Fit :-). The point being is that the Tickr Fit beats the Scosche Rhythm in every material respect I can think of.

Comparing the Tickr Fit to the OH1 is different again. Both are equally as accurate but the Tickr easily wins on battery life. Then again the OH1 can very readily be used for swimming where it caches HR unlike the Tickr Fit.

The OH1 also has caching functionality for gym use via the Polar beat app. But the Polar is Bluetooth Smart only.

Summary

Clearly this Wahoo Tickr Fit Review finds a great optical heart rate monitor.

The key areas where the Wahoo Tickr Fit wins are

  • Accuracy (provisionally good)
  • Openness to ANT+ and BLE
  • Market-leading battery life

Whilst the broad price level IS currently justified (Jan 2018), some of the alterative products offer a broader range of functionality. Whether or not you need those functionalities is another matter entirely. There could be longer term downward pressure on prices as cheaper, unbranded dual-band products start to come on to the market throughout 2018.

My hope is that Wahoo will use the Tickr Fit to do more with the optical technology AND that they already have extra hardware capabilities built in to the product that hopefully will be enabled in future firmware updates. Don’t buy on that hope though!

Discount, Availability & Price

If you’d like to help this blog please use the live amazon prices below.

Best Amazon price is linked to. $/Eu/£70 and UNlikely to fall in 2018/9. Buying from Amazon supports this site

Best Amazon price is linked to. $80/Eu80/£65 and UNlikely to fall in 2018/9. Buying from Amazon supports this site

Best Amazon price is linked to. $80/Eu80/£70 and likely to fall in 2018 as a new version is released. Buying from Amazon supports this site

Supporters: I am not a salaried journalist and rely on support from readers to keep the free content coming. If you want to support the work here then ad-free subscription starts at 49p (about 65c). Alternatively buying anything from my partners, below, also helps and may also get you a great discount. Thank you!

Support with 10% code: the5krunner10Support at your local country’s Amazon storefrontSupport with 10% code: the5krunner1010% Discount On Most Power Meters

21
Leave a Reply here

avatar
8 Comment threads
13 Thread replies
1 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
9 Comment authors
KateMichaelPatriceChrisBoris Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
gingerneil
Guest

Looks like a very good bit of kit – and I’ll be picking one up as soon as they are available on Amazon uk.

the5krunner
Admin

thank you for the support

Justin
Member
Justin

I bought one (using your link). I’ve never been let down by a single Wahoo product so far. Couple that with the awesome battery life and dual band connection and i’m sold. My Scosche Rhythm + on the other hand gave me lots of connection problems (over multiple devices).

Didn’t matter where I wore it, it just would drop out for a spell every few minutes. And I wore that band everywhere on my arms; it would drop out no matter. Only static place I found that wasn’t the worst was on my opposite bicep to my watch arm, but I found that I had no good place to tighten it. Either it was loose and would slide or it was restrictive and hurt my arm. I’m hoping the larger strap included with the Tickr Fit makes for a better fit.

I’m going to play around with it and see how close the Tickr fit is to my HRM-Tri…just one question. Where (how) are you plugging HR data in to see the side-by-side comparison. I think I asked DCR once but I didn’t get a straight response for it.

gingerneil
Guest
gingerneil

The graphics above look like SportTracks – DCR also has a data analyser that can do this, for a small charge.

the5krunner
Admin

yes I might subscribe to that. he needs the money.

the5krunner
Admin

thank you!

Webvan
Guest
Webvan

Thanks for the review. Too bad about HRV data not coming through, could you try it with Elite HRV when you get a chance as I wonder whether Bioforce HRV is not limited to some stazps?

Boris
Guest

Optical HR has so much „lag“. For solid HRV results you need at least a „resolution“ of 500-1000Hz. E.g. stationary medical equipment for HRV works with „resolution“ of 4000-6000Hz.

In other words: It‘s good, that HRV is not „enabled“ – better no HRV coming through, than fake one. ?

the5krunner
Admin

just tried and didnt even recognisethe tickr fit
caveat: my android phone is not supported.

Webvan
Guest
Webvan

Thanks for checking.

On the subject of HRV, have you tried the HRV4Training app ? There’s an Android version since March and it’s really quite nice IF your phone’s camera is up to snuff. I used it with my H7 originally but it’s so much easier to just take a measurement with your finger on the lens. They get the Strava workouts so can compute some nice training related data.

They have a ton of stuff on their blog about validating the optical measurement, the variation of HRV from one measurement to another…within 3 consecutive minutes, etc…

the5krunner
Admin

i tried it a LONG time ago and i have seen some of the research…again a while back.
my mind has wandered away from hrv in recent years. I got disillusioned that it couldn’t do what i wanted it to

Justin
Member
Justin

I don’t know if anyone is going to read this, but I just received the tickr fit and was able to do the HRV Stress test with it via the forerunner 935 stress test. I don’t know if they changed something but it did take the measure there.

the5krunner
Admin

this test: https://www.firstbeat.com/en/consumer-feature/quick-stress-level-test/
this doc (may be similar to website): https://docs.google.com/document/d/18GKpGoPGSLirK8SNF9_KT0hCJoo2l2EGWD8FjWy3q8Y/edit#heading=h.oo5fdzc6h75a

the mio link used to produce hrv data…or at least it could be interpreted as such. didn’t mean to say it was right. sometimes even agreed with my hr strap
i’m not sure but i doubt it will be hrv. Boris might have somethign to say about the quality of the signal to give meaningful results.

Chris
Guest
Chris

Would you recommend the Fit over the Tickr X at all? Am a bit of a newbie and not sure which would best suit my needs (mostly running up to Half Marathon) better as they are similar prices.

the5krunner
Admin

they should be similarly accurate but obvisouly one is for the arm and the other for the chest
i’d imagine either would be fine
thank you for your support buying from one of the amazon links !! 😉

Kate
Guest
Kate

Tickr X has an accelerometer as well as heart rate monitoring

Patrice
Guest
Patrice

Tks for this review. I’am on an expert…is this optical monitor is compatible with my polar v800 ?

the5krunner
Admin

yes

Michael
Guest
Michael

Looks like wiggle have stopped stocking them. That could not be a good sign.

the5krunner
Admin

it does say “email me when in stock”
maybe they sold out so quickly 😉

Webvan
Guest
Webvan

“There are cheap OEM/generic bands waiting to hit the market in Q1.2018”

Looks they’ve now arrived with the Runar BT/ANT+on Amazon for less than 50% of the price of the Wahoo/Polar/Scosche…Is that the one you tried ? How did you like it ? There’s a review out there that says it’s not very accurate…