Scosche Rhythm+ 2.0 | Beats OH1+ ? Where are Garmin?

FTC: Affiliate Disclosure: All links pay commissionReading Time: 2 minutes

Scosche Rhythm+ 2.0

Scosche’s first foray into optical HR tech was with their Scosche Rhythm/Rhythm+ armband followed by the Rhythm 24 in 2018. I have an original Rhythm and it is a sound product that delivers decent HR and it had a very good reputation for accuracy which wore off on Valencell who provide the sensor. That probably helped Valencell becomes Suunto’s first supplier.

It took everyone a little while to realise that it wasn’t the Valencell sensor that was great per see but rather it was that wearing any old optical HR strap on your upper arm is generally a good approach both for comfort and accuracy.

Now we have Rhythm+ 2.0 which I discuss below and I expect to have good accuracy.

Polar OH1+ and Garmin

The elephant in the room is Garmin. Why haven’t they repackaged their ELEVATE Gen 3 sensor and made an armband product like Scosche and Polar? Answer?… I don’t know.

The baby elephant in the room is the Polar OH1+. It’s a great optical armband product and I can see few reasons for using something else except price, strap width; better battery life, better low battery indication and more advanced features like ANT+ caching.

Which brings us on to the Scosche.

 

Scosche Rhythm+ 2.0  | What’s new?

Not a lot is new, at least not much that seems important.

The battery life is unchanged at 24 hours and both BLE and ANT+ broadcasting are still supported. Does this mean that Scosche dropped all intention for caching to support swimming and the high-end Garmin sports watches? Maybe, but if they were planning to do that you would have thought that better waterproofing than IP68 would have been introduced.

Then we come to the strap. Technophiles love the specs but the success of this product will likely come down to the strap. And this strap looks good. A wider strap is more comfortable and more importantly, it’s less likely to flip. I still regularly use my Polar OH1+ however, if I’m not careful, it will flip when I put clothes over it. It was fine when new but as the strap has weakened slightly over many months of use, flipping is more notable both in swimming and other usages.

I’ve not really mentioned the Wahoo TICKR Fit which I also have. Everyone loves a good Wahoo product but this one is not as accurate as the Polar OH1+, so I don’t use it. Let’s also not forget the mioPOD which is accurate. I would also class the Polar as ‘ACCURATE’.

I’m not sure I’ll review the Rhythm+ 2.0 unless it can cache to a Garmin, I’m happy enough with the OH1+.

At $79.99 it’s sensibly priced but there are unbranded alternatives on Amazon for half the price.

Sources: dcrainmaker, Scosche

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Reader-Powered Content

Follow the5krunner
This content is not sponsored. It's mostly me behind the labour of love which is this site, meaning it's entirely reader-powered content ❤️ I'd really appreciate it if you'd follow, subscribe or Buy Me A Coffee ❤️ Alternatively please buy the reviewed product from my partners (which costs you no extra) and, for that, I receive a small commission. Thank you!
FTC: Affiliate Disclosure: All links pay commission
thank you for completing your purchase here - choice of local retailers
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
30 Comments
oldest
newest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Jacob

When garmin will have some kind of annoucments on CES 2021? ( i mean which day )

webvan

So much for the 955 then…any sense of an ETA ?

webvan

If it’s January and since they are at CES, it seems like a missed opportunity if they don’t announce anything over there 🙁 I hope it’s a 955 since it doesn’t seem like Garmin have anything in place for LTE in Europe ?

RandomReader

What about this?
Fresh off the FCC website (2021-01-08)

Doesn’t specifically say smartwatch but some of the documents available basically make it look like a Fenix-like model

https://fccid.io/IPH-03992/

tfk, the5krunner

its taken a while, nice find! the images in it effectively say SOLAR and it looks like the rear case layout of a fenix. It has NFC therefore probably Garmin PAY. so its not a low end model. guess it could be the fenix 7 maybe MARQ v2

i think this listing was already on the fcc site but has had info in it changed eg I think it was earlier set for a release last week and that it did not have NFC until now.

Jacob

So Jan release more probably fenix 7?

tfk, the5krunner

that’s one reasonable interpretation

Jacob

Maybe they ditched forerunner flagship line

Jacob

Whats that ?

webvan

Wondering too as I can’t find any pictures in the documents I’ve opened.

webvan

Which documents specifically ? It seems the actual pictures are embargoed until 2021-04-08?

tfk, the5krunner

hmm that’s 2 years since MARQ v1 was released

tfk, the5krunner

its the 2x Enduros

Jacob

they are exhibiting :/

Jacob

imho if it will be 945 lte it is shame :/ battery life would be really weak

RaulV

I know 2 reasons for Garmin’s absence:

  • they lack an immense amount of feeling with end users
  • all personel is busy taking care of it’s own terrritory, no one is taking the trouble of doing something extra/having some kind of vision etc. Already an aspect of the organisation for many years….. No creativity. No innovation. Now & then they buy a company that has produced something interesting. Often that seems not so interesting after all.
Jacob

Interesting opinion, even more interesting why there is no leaks at all at launch this month

Jojo

this was from a mothns ago and is set for this month
it has no nfc chip therefore is not 955
maybe this is a stryd or armband?
https://fccid.io/IPH-03927

Jacob

And its called smartwatch

tfk, the5krunner

there some kids band/vivo thing due. i’m not so interested in that but it could be the one in the link you refer to perhaps?

Stromz

Interesting, think Ray reported that there is no HRV for this 2.0 version?

Jason

Hard pass unless they fix the core issue I had with both the Rhythm and the Wahoo – plastic mounting hardware. Both of them busted on me because the plastic that holds on the strap eventually broke. It took maybe a year.

Pretty sure any such design will inherently break. OH1 is good because you could just buy a new strap since it snaps-in to strap, but even their strap seems unlikely to break because it’s not a typical pin-in-plastic type design.

Between sunlight, heat, cold, and especially sunblock any small piece of plastic that is in the critical path of mounting will likely break.