Garmin CIRQA Smart Band: The Thin Sensor Explanation Does Not Add Up
Garmin has explained why the CIRQA Smart Band uses the older Elevate Gen 4 sensor rather than the Gen 5 in its current watches. Product manager Chrissy Wheeler told Forbes it came down to size: “The reason we didn’t go for the very latest one is the size of the module.” The Gen 5, she said, would have made the band thicker.
Hmm. Really? I don’t think so. Here’s why.
Fact: Garmin already sells a thinner device with the newer sensor inside it. The Index Sleep Monitor uses Elevate Gen 5 (with ECG disabled) and is 7.8mm thick. The CIRQA uses Elevate Gen 4/4.1 and is 9mm thick.
A wider pod lets components lie flat, which is part of how the 37.6mm Index Sleep Monitor reaches 7.8mm. The narrow CIRQA has to stack them. That is the shape Garmin chose, not a limit the sensor imposed.
Gen 5 is the physically larger sensor, because it adds emitters that help when a heavier watch moves around during hard efforts. A light band moves less and needs them less. That is a fair reason to prefer Gen 4 here, but it is not the reason Garmin gave, and it is a point about width rather than thickness. Either way, the Index Sleep Monitor carries Gen 5 in a thinner body, so neither framing holds.
The likelier reasons are the two Garmin did not give: Elevate Gen 4 is cheaper, and it draws less power, which matters on a band selling at $199.99 delivering a ten-day battery.
Full specifications are at the Garmin CIRQA specs page. Whether the older sensor actually costs CIRQA accuracy is tested directly in the full review: excellent in the gym, yoga and cycling, with failures specific to open water swimming and running intervals.
Garmin CIRQA Smart Band
Screenless health and fitness band (no subscription required)
RRP £179.99
$199.99/€199.99
- use code:
Get it nowOrder now – Garmin CIRQA Smart Band Also sold direct byQuick answers
Why does the Garmin CIRQA use the older Elevate Gen 4 sensor?
Garmin says the Gen 5 sensor would have made the module thicker. That explanation is hard to square with Garmin’s own Index Sleep Monitor, which carries Gen 5 at 7.8mm against the CIRQA’s 9mm. The likelier reasons are cost and battery draw, since Gen 4 is cheaper and draws less power, which suits a $199.99 band with a ten-day battery.
Is the Garmin CIRQA less accurate because of the Gen 4 sensor?
Not necessarily. Fit, placement and movement affect optical readings as much as sensor generation, and the CIRQA’s Gen 4 has been modified to add skin temperature. Published Gen 4 versus Gen 5 comparisons predate this variant, so it needs its own testing.
How thick is the Garmin CIRQA compared to the Index Sleep Monitor?
The CIRQA module is 9mm thick. The Index Sleep Monitor is 7.8mm thick and uses the newer Elevate Gen 5 sensor. The Index Sleep Monitor pod is also wider, which allows a thinner build for the same internals.
Last Updated on 3 October 2026 by tfk the5krunner
Small things I always use
- Garmin 90-degree charging adapter: Charges your Garmin from any USB-C cable. Essential when travelling. I use one.
- Body Glide: The blue anti-chafe stick swimmers and runners carry. I use it.
- Speedo earplugs: Fewer ear infections and no cold-water dizziness. I use them.
- Dryrobe Advance: My winter changing robe for open-water swims. I use one. A cheaper option is the AONYIYI changing robe.
- Maurten: Race fuel that stays easy on the stomach. I use them.
- Beet It Sport nitrate shots: Beetroot shots I take in the days before a race. I use them.
- Garmin charging puck: The quickest way to top up before a session. I use one.
- Injinji: Toe socks that stop rubbing, so you run more. I use them.
- Ultimate toe protectors: Stop black toenails on long runs. They work. I use them.
- Compressport R2 v2 calf sleeves: My calf sleeves of choice. I use them.
- Cellucor C4: My pre-workout before hard sessions.
- TPU tubes: Schwalbe Aerothan, Tubolito and Pirelli SmarTube. Light, tiny spares. I use all three.
- G8 insoles: Adjustable insoles that are good. I use them.
- Cycplus Cube: A 97g electric pump that gets a road tyre rideable in two minutes. I carry one. 5% off with code THE5KRUNNER.
Watches and sensors
- Polar H10: My daily driver for waking HRV.
- Polar Verity Sense: My backup arm-worn HR sensor.
- Nomad bedside charger: Charges my iPhone and Apple Watch overnight. I use it, and many of their bands.
- Train.Red: The best muscle oxygen sensor I’ve used.
- Tymewear: Accurate heart rate and reliable ventilatory zones. I use it to pace endurance rides over an hour.
- Garmin Forerunner 970: A pro-grade triathlon watch. I use this.
- Apple Watch Ultra 4: My daily smartwatch. No phone needed on rides.
- Garmin Fenix 9 Pro: I’ve just bought one.
On the bike
- Continental GP5000 for everyday riding, and Aero 111 on the front for special occasions.
- Helmets: Specialized S-Works Evade 3 for road riding, and Rudy Project Wing for TT-style races. I use both.
- Ravemen FR300: A front light that mounts under your Garmin or Wahoo. I use one.
- Wahoo TRACKR Radar: I use it on one bike and Varia on the other. They perform the same.
- Garmin Varia RTL515: Radar that warns you of cars from behind. I use this model.
- Wahoo ELEMNT Roam 3: The bike computer that’s easy to use. I use mine on most rides.
- Favero Assioma Pro RS2: Accurate power pedals that swap easily between bikes. I use this model.
Home and indoor training
- NPE Runn: Makes my basic treadmill smart, sending more accurate speed and distance to my watch and Zwift. I use it.
- Google Wifi: Keeps Zwift connected in my pain cave. I use it.
- Apple TV 4K: Zwift on the big screen. I use two.
- Google Nest Doorbell (wired, 2nd gen): My video doorbell, running in both Google Home and Apple Home. I use it.
Health, recovery and sleep
- FreeStyle Libre 3 Plus: Shows how my blood sugar responds to diet.
- hDrop: Measures my sweat loss in summer and indoors.
- Fourth Frontier Zone: Checks my heart under load in hard sessions.
- Oura Ring 5: My partner’s recovery tracker of choice.
- Eight Sleep: A cooling mattress cover my partner and I use nightly.
Reader-Powered Content
This content is not sponsored. It’s mostly me behind the labour of love, which is this site, and I appreciate everyone who supports it.
Support the site: Follow (free, fewer ads) · Subscribe (paid, ad-free) · Buy Me A Coffee
Written by real people, with AI assistance. Fact-checked and verified for originality. See the Editorial Policy. FTC: Affiliate Disclosure — some links pay commission. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
tfk is the founder and author of the5krunner, an independent endurance sports technology publication. With 20 years of hands-on testing of GPS watches and wearables, and competing in triathlons at an international age-group level, tfk provides in-depth expert analysis of fitness technology for serious athletes and endurance sport competitors. See the gear tfk uses. ID
Venu X1 (7.9 mm thin) is also thinner than Cirqa but uses Elevate 5. This is really strange.
tell that to the Garmin product manager!
(well spotted, i missed that one)
But the X1 doesn’t get 10 days of battery life…..
A thicker band could also refer to width of the band on your arm. Notice people complaining the band is wider then the fitbit air? They may not have wanted it any wider